The Brimming Cup
CHAPTER VII
THE NIGHT-BLOOMING CEREUS
An Evening in the Life of Mrs. Neale
Crittenden
April 20.
Nowadays she so seldom spoke or acted without knowing perfectly
well what she was about, that Marise startled herself almost as
much as her callers by turning over that leaf in the photograph
album quickly and saying with abruptness, "No, never mind about
that one. It's nothing interesting."
Of course this brought out from Paul and little Mark, hanging
over her shoulder and knee, the to-be-expected shouts of, "Oh,
let's see it! What is it?"
Marise perceived that they scented something fine and exciting
such as Mother was always trying to keep from them, like one man
choking another over the edge of a cliff, or a woman lying on her
back with the blood all running from her throat. Whenever pictures
like that were in any of the magazines that came into the house,
Marise took them away from the little boys, although she knew
helplessly that this naturally made them extremely keen not to miss
any chance to catch a glimpse of such a one. She could see that
they thought it queer, there being anything so exciting in this old
album of dull snapshots and geographical picture-postcards of
places and churches and ruins and things that Father and Mother had
seen, so long ago. But you never could tell. The way Mother had
spoken, the sound of her voice, the way she had flapped down the
page quick, the little boys' practised ears and eyes had identified
all that to a certainty with the actions that accompanied pictures
she didn't want them to see. So, of course, they clamored, "Oh
yes, Mother, just one look!"
Elly as usual said nothing, looking up into Mother's face.
Marise was extremely annoyed. She was glad that Elly was the only
one who was looking at her, because, of course, dear old Mr.
Welles' unobservant eyes didn't count. She was glad that Mr. Marsh
kept his gaze downward on the photograph marked "Rome from the
Pincian Gardens," although through the top of his dark,
close-cropped head she could fairly feel the racing, inquiring
speculations whirling about. Nor had she any right to resent that.
She supposed people had a right to what went on in their own heads,
so long as they kept it to themselves. And it had been unexpectedly
delicate and fine, the way he had come to understand, without a
syllable spoken on either side, that that piercing look of his made
her uneasy; and how he had promised her, wordlessly always, to bend
it on her no more.
Why in the world had it made her uneasy, and why, a
thousand times why, had she felt this sudden unwillingness to look
at the perfectly commonplace photograph, in this company? Something
had burst up from the subconscious and flashed its way into action,
moving her tongue to speak and her hand to action before she had
the faintest idea it was there . . . like an action of youth! And
see what a silly position it had put her in!
The little boys had succeeded with the inspired tactlessness of
children in emphasizing and exaggerating what she had wished could
be passed over unnoticed, a gesture of hers as inexplicable to her
as to them. Oh well, the best thing, of course, was to carry it off
matter-of-factly, turn the leaf back, and let them see it.
And then refute them by insisting on the literal truth of what she
had said.
"There!" she said carelessly; "look at it then."
The little boys bent their eager faces over it. Paul read out
the title as he had been doing for the other photographs, "'View of
the Campagna from the top of the cable-railway at Rocca di Papa.
Rome in the distance.'"
She had to sustain, for an instant, an astonished and
disconcerted look from all those eyes. It made her quite genuinely
break into a laugh. It was really a joke on them. She said to the
little boys mischievously, "What did Mother say? Do you find it
very interesting?"
Paul and Mark stared hard at the very dull photograph of a cliff
and a plain and not even a single person or donkey in it, and gave
up the riddle. Mother certainly had spoken to them in that
hide-it-away-from-the-children voice, and yet there was nothing
there.
Marise knew that they felt somehow that Mother had unfairly
slipped out between their fingers, as grown-ups are always doing.
Well, it wasn't fair. She hated taking advantage of them like that.
It was a sort of sin against their awakening capacity to put two
and two together and make a human total, and understand what went
on about them.
But it hadn't been against their capacity to put two and
two together that she had instinctively thrown up that warding-off
arm, which hadn't at all warded off attention, but rather drawn it
hard and scrutinizing, in spite of those down-dropped sharp eyes.
Well, there was no sum he could do with only two, and slight
probability he would ever get the other two to put with it . . .
whatever the other two might be.
Mr. Welles' pleasant old voice said, "It's a very pretty
picture, I'm sure. They certainly have very fine views about the
Eternal City. I envy you your acquaintance with all those historic
spots. What is the next one?"
Dear old Mr. Welles! What a restful presence! How unutterably
sweet and uncomplicated life could be with a good big dose of
simplicity holding everything in a clear solution, so that it never
occurred to you that what things seemed was very different from
what they were.
"Ready to turn over, dears?" she asked the little boys. This
time she was in her usual control of the machine, regulated what
she did from the first motion to the last, made her voice casual
but not elaborately so, and put one arm around Mark's slim little
shoulder with just the right degree of uninterest in those old and
faded photographs.
Very deep down, at the edge of consciousness, something asked
her, "Why did you try to hide that photograph?"
She could not answer this question. She didn't know why, any
more than the little boys did. And it wouldn't do now, with the
need to be mistress-of-the-house till a call ended, to stop to try
to think it out. Later on, tonight, after the children were in bed,
when she was brushing her hair . . . oh, probably she'd find as you
so often did, when you went after the cause of some unexpected
little feeling, that it came from a meaningless fortuitous
association of ideas, like Elly's hatred of grape-jelly because she
had once taken some bitter medicine in it.
"'View of the Roman Aqueduct, taken from the tramway line to
Tivoli,'" read out Paul.
"Very pretty view," said Mr. Welles.
Mr. Marsh's silences were as abysmal as his speech was
Niagara-like on occasion. He said nothing.
Elly stirred and looked toward the doorway. Touclé stood
there, her shoe-button eyes not blinking in the lamp-light although
she probably had been sitting on the steps of the kitchen, looking
out into the darkness, in the long, motionless vigil which made up
Touclé's evenings. As they all turned their faces towards
her, she said, "The cereus is going to bloom tonight," and
disappeared.
Marise welcomed this diversion. Ever since that absurd little
gesture about the photograph, she had felt thickening about her . .
. what? What you call "depression" (whatever that meant), the dull
hooded apparition that came blackly and laid its leaden hand on
your heart. This news was just the thing. It would change what was
threatening to stand stagnant and charge it with fresh running
currents. She got up briskly to her feet.
"Come on, children," she said. "I'll let you sit up beyond
bed-time tonight. Scatter quick, and put on your things. We'll all
go down the road to the Powers house and see the cereus in
bloom."
The children ducked quickly out of the room, thudding along
softly in their felt slippers. Scramblings, chatterings, and
stamping sounded back from the front hall, as they put on their
boots and wraps.
"Wouldn't you like to come, too?" she asked the men, rescuing
them from the rather high-and-dry position in which this unexpected
incident had left them. It was plainly, from their faces, as
inexplicable as unexpected. She explained, drawing a long, plain,
black silk scarf closely about her head and shoulders, "Why, yes,
do come. It's an occasion as uniquely Ashleyian as pelota is
Basque. You, Mr. Marsh, with your exhaustive inquiries into the
habits and manners of Vermont mountaineers, your data won't be
complete unless you've seen Nelly Powers' night-blooming cereus in
its one hour of glory. Seriously, I assure you, you won't encounter
anything like it, anywhere else."
As Marsh looked at her, she noted with an inward amusement that
her words had lighted a smouldering glow of carefully repressed
exasperation in his eyes. It made her feel quite gay and young to
be teasing somebody again. She was only paying him back in his own
coin. He himself was always telling everybody about his deep
interest in the curious quaint ways of these mountaineers. And if
he didn't have a deep interest in their curious quaint ways, what
else could he give as a reason for staying on in the valley?
The men turned away to get their hats. She settled the folds of
her heavy black silk mantilla more closely about her head, glancing
at herself in the mirror. She smiled back with sympathy at the
smiling face she saw there. It was not so often since the war that
she saw her own face lighted with mirth.
Gravely, something deep on the edge of the unconscious called up
to her, "You are talking and feeling like a coquette."
She was indignant at this, up in arms to defend human freedom.
"Oh, what a hateful, little-villagey, prudish, nasty-minded idea!"
she cried to herself. "Who would have thought that narrowness and
priggishness could rub off on a person's mind like that! Mrs.
Bayweather could have thought that! Mercy! As if one civilized
being can't indulge in a light touch or two in human intercourse
with another!"
The two men were ready now and all the party of six jostled each
other cheerfully as they went out of the front door. Paul had
secured the hand of old Mr. Welles and led him along with an air of
proprietary affection.
"Don't you turn out the lamp, or lock the door, or
anything?" asked the old man, now.
"Oh no, we won't be gone long. It's not more than half a mile to
the Powers'. There's not a soul in the valley who would think of
going in and rummaging . . . let alone taking anything. And we
never have tramps. We are too far from the railroad," said
Marise.
"Well!" exclaimed the other, looking back as they went
down the path, "it certainly looks queer to me, the door standing
open into this black night, and the light shining in that empty
room."
Elly looked back too. She slipped her hand out of her mother's
and ran towards the house. She darted up to the door and stood
there, poised like a swallow, looking in.
"What does she want?" asked Mr. Welles with the naïve
conviction of the elderly bachelor that the mother must know
everything in the child's mind.
"I don't know," admitted Marise. "Nobody ever knows exactly what
is in Elly's mind when she does things. Maybe she is looking to see
that her kitten is safe."
The little girl ran back to them.
"What did you want, dear?" asked her mother.
"I just wanted to look at it again," said Elly. "I like
it, like that, all quiet, with nobody in it. The furniture looks as
though it were having a good rest from us."
"Oh, listen to the frogs!" screamed Mark, out of the darkness
where he had run to join Touclé.
Elly and Paul sprang forward to join their little brother.
"What in the world are we going to see?" asked Marsh. "You
forget you haven't given us the least idea."
"You are going to see," Marise set herself to amuse them,
"you're going to see a rite of the worship of beauty which Ashley,
Vermont, has created out of its own inner consciousness."
She had succeeded in amusing at least one of them, for at this
Mr. Marsh gave her the not disagreeable shock of that singular,
loud laugh of his. It was in conversation like something-or-other
in the orchestra . . . the cymbals, that must be it . . . made you
jump, and tingle with answering vibrations.
"Ashleyians in the rôle of worshipers of beauty!" he
cried, out of the soft, moist, dense darkness about them.
"None so blind as those who won't see," she persisted. "Just
because they go to it in overalls and gingham aprons, instead of
peplums and sandals."
"What is a night-blooming cereal?" asked Mr. Welles,
patient of the verbose by-play of his companions that never got
anybody anywhere.
What an old dear Mr. Welles was! thought Marise. It was like
having the sweetest old uncle bestowed on you as a pendant to dear
Cousin Hetty.
". . . -eus, not -eal," murmured Marsh; "not that I know any
more than you what it is."
Marise felt suddenly wrought upon by the mildness of the spring
air, the high, tuneful shrillness of the frogs' voices, the
darkness, sweet and thick. She would not amuse them; no, she would
really tell them, move them. She chose the deeper intonations of
her voice, she selected her words with care, she played upon her
own feeling, quickening it into genuine emotion as she spoke. She
would make them feel it too.
"It is a plant of the cactus family, as native to America as is
Ashley's peculiar sense of beauty which you won't acknowledge. It
is as ugly to look at, the plant is, all spines and thick,
graceless, fleshy pads; as ugly as Ashley life looks to you. And
this crabbed, ungainly plant-creature is faithfully, religiously
tended all the year around by the wife of a farmer, because once a
year, just once, it puts forth a wonderful exotic flower of extreme
beauty. When the bud begins to show its color she sends out word to
all her neighbors to be ready. And we are all ready. For days, in
the back of our minds as we go about our dull, routine life, there
is the thought that the cereus is near to bloom. Nelly and her grim
husband hang over it day by day, watching it slowly prepare for its
hour of glory. Sometimes when they cannot decide just the time it
will open, they sit up all through a long night, hour after hour of
darkness and silence, to make sure that it does not bloom unseen.
When they see that it is about to open, they fling open their
doors, wishing above everything else to share that beauty with
their fellows. Their children are sent to announce, as you heard
Touclé say tonight, 'The cereus is going to bloom.' And all
up and down this end of the valley, in those ugly little wooden
houses that look so mean and dreary to you, everywhere people tired
from their day's struggle with the earth, rise up and go their
pilgrimage through the night . . . for what? To see something rare
and beautiful."
She stopped speaking. On one side of her she heard the voice of
the older man say with a quiver, "Well, I can understand why your
neighbors love you."
With entire unexpectedness Marsh answered fiercely from the
other side, "They don't love her! They're not capable of
it!"
Marise started, as though a charged electric wire had fallen
across her arm. Why was there so often a note of anger in his
voice?
For a moment they advanced silently, pacing forward, side by
side, unseen but not unfelt by each of the others.
The road turned now and they were before the little house, every
window alight, the great pine somber and high before it. The
children and Touclé were waiting at the door. They all went
in together, shaking hands with the mistress of the house, neatly
dressed, with a clean, white flounced apron. "Nelly's garment of
ceremony!" thought Marise.
Nelly acknowledged, with a graceful, silent inclination of her
shining blonde head, the presence of the two strangers whom Marise
presented to her. What an inscrutable fascination Nelly's silence
gave to her! You never knew what strange thoughts were going on
behind that proud taciturnity. She showed the guests to chairs, of
which a great many, mostly already filled, stood about the center
table, on which sprawled the great, spiny, unlovely plant. Marise
sat down, taking little Mark on her knees. Elly leaned against her.
Paul sat close beside old Mr. Welles. Their eyes were on the big
pink bud enthroned in the uncomeliness of the shapeless
leafpads.
"Oh!" said Elly, under her breath, "it's not open yet! We're
going to see it open, this time!" She stared at it, her lips
parted. Her mother looked at her, tenderly aware that the child was
storing away an impression to last her life long. Dear, strangely
compounded little Elly, with her mysticism, and her greediness and
her love of beauty all jumbled together! A neighbor leaned from her
chair to say to Mrs. Crittenden, "Warm for this time of year, ain't
it?" And another remarked, looking at Mark's little trousers, "That
material come out real good, didn't it? I made up what I got of it,
into a dress for Pearl." They both spoke in low tones, but
constrained or sepulchral, for they smiled and nodded as though
they had meant something else and deeper than what they had said.
They looked with a kindly expression for moment at the Crittenden
children and then turned back to their gaze on the flower-bud.
Nelly Powers, walking with a singular lightness for so tall a
woman, ushered in another group of visitors—a tall, unshaven
farmer, his wife, three little children clumping in on shapeless
cow-hide boots, and a baby, fast asleep, its round bonneted head
tucked in the hollow of its mother's gingham-clad shoulder. They
sat down, nodding silent greetings to the other neighbors. In
turning to salute them, Marise caught a glimpse of Mr. Marsh,
fixing his brilliant scrutiny first on one and then on another of
the company. At that moment he was gazing at Nelly Powers, "taking
her in" thought Marise, from her beautiful hair to those
preposterously high-heeled shoes she always would wear on her
shapely feet. His face was impassive. When he looked neutral like
that, the curious irregularity of his features came out strongly.
He looked like that bust of Julius Caesar, the bumpy, big-nosed,
strong-chinned one, all but that thick, closely cut, low-growing
head of dark hair.
She glanced at Mr. Welles, and was surprised to find that he was
looking neither at the people nor the plant. His arm was around his
favorite Paul, but his gaze seemed turned inward, as though he were
thinking of something very far away. He looked tired and old, it
seemed to her, and without that quietly shining aspect of peace
which she found so touching. Perhaps he was tired. Perhaps she
ought not to have brought him out, this evening, for that long walk
over rough country roads. How much older he was than his real age
in years! His life had used him up. There must have been some inner
maladjustment in it!
There was a little stir in the company, a small inarticulate
sound from Elly. Marise saw everyone's eyes turn to the center of
the room and looked back to the plant. The big pink bud was
beginning visibly to swell.
A silence came into the room. No one coughed, or stirred, or
scraped a chair-leg. It was as though a sound would have wounded
the flower. All those human souls bowed themselves. Almost a light
shone upon them . . . a phrase from Dante came to Marise's mind . .
. "la mia menta fu percossa da un fulgore . . ."
With a quick involuntary turn she looked at Marsh, fearing his
mockery of her, "quoting the Paradiso, about Vermont
farmers!" as though he could know, for all those sharp eyes of his,
what was going on hidden in her mind!
All this came and went in an instant, for she now saw that one
big, shining petal was slowly, slowly, but quite visibly uncurling
at the tip. From that moment on, she saw nothing, felt nothing but
the opening flower, lived only in the incredibly leisurely,
masterful motion with which the grotesquely shaped protecting
petals curled themselves back from the center. Their motion was so
slow that the mind was lost in dreaminess in following it. Had that
last one moved? No, it stood still, poised breathlessly . . . and
yet, there before them, revealed, exultant, the starry heart of the
great flower shimmered in the lamp-light.
Then she realized that she had not breathed. She drew in a great
marveling aspiration, and heard everyone about her do the same.
They turned to each other with inarticulate exclamations, shaking
their heads wonderingly, their lips a little apart as they drew
long breaths.
Two very old women, rubbing their age-dimmed eyes, stood up,
tiptoed to the table, and bent above the miraculously fine texture
of the flower their worn and wrinkled faces. The petals cast a
clear, rosy reflection upon their sallow cheeks. Some of the
younger mothers took their little children over to the table and
lifting them up till their round shining eyes were on a level with
the flower, let them gaze their fill at the mysterious splendor of
stamen and pistil.
"Would you like to go quite close and look at it, children?"
Marise asked her own brood.
The little boys stepped forward at once, curiously, but Elly
said, "No, oh no!" and backed off till she stood leaning
against Touclé's knee. The old woman put her dark hand down
gently on the child's soft hair and smiled at her. How curious it
was to see that grim, battered old visage smile! Elly was the only
creature in the world at whom the old Indian ever smiled, indeed
almost the only thing in the house which those absent old eyes ever
seemed to see. Marise remembered that Touclé had smiled when
she first took the baby Elly in her arms.
A little murmur of talk arose now, from the assembled neighbors.
They stood up, moved about, exchanged a few laconic greetings, and
began putting their wraps on. Marise remembered that Mr. Welles had
seemed tired and as soon as possible set her party in motion.
"Thank you so much, Nelly, for letting us know," she said to the
farmer's wife, as they came away. "It wouldn't seem like a year in
our valley if we didn't see your cereus in bloom."
She took Elly's hand in one of hers, and with Mark on the other
side walked down the path to the road. The darkness was intense
there, because of the gigantic pine-tree which towered above the
little house. "Are you there, Paul?" she called through the
blackness. The little boy's voice came back, "Yes, with
Touclé, we're ahead." The two men walked behind.
Elly's hand was hot and clasped her mother's very tightly.
Marise bent over the little girl and divined in the darkness that
she was crying. "Why, Elly darling, what's the matter?" she
asked.
The child cried out passionately, on a mounting note, "Nothing,
nothing! Nothing!" She flung her arms around her mother's
neck, straining her close in a wild embrace. Little Mark, on the
other side, yawned and staggered sleepily on his feet. Elly gave
her mother a last kiss, and ran on ahead, calling over her
shoulder, "I'm going to walk by myself!"
"Well!" commented the old gentleman.
Mr. Marsh had not been interested in this episode and had stood
gazing admiringly up at the huge pine-tree, divining its bulk and
mass against the black sky.
"Like Milton's Satan, isn't it?" was his comment as they walked
on, "with apologies for the triteness of the quotation."
For a time nothing was said, and then Marsh began, "Now I've
seen it, your rite of the worship of beauty. And do you know what
was really there? A handful of dull, insensitive, primitive beings,
hardened and calloused by manual toil and atrophied imaginations,
so starved for any variety in their stupefyingly monotonous life
that they welcome anything, anything at all as a break . . . only
if they could choose, they would infinitely prefer a two-headed
calf or a bearded woman to your flower. The only reason they go to
see that is because it is a curiosity, not because of its beauty,
because it blooms once a year only, at night, and because there is
only one of them in town. Also because everybody else goes to see
it. They go to look at it only because there aren't any movies in
Ashley, nor anything else. And you know all this just as well as I
do."
"Oh, Mr. Welles," Marise appealed to him, "do you think that is
the truth of the facts?"
The old man pronounced judgment gently. "Well, I don't know that
anything is the truth. I should say that both of you told
the truth about it. The truth's pretty big for any one person to
tell. Isn't it all in the way you look at it?" He added, "Only
personally I think Mrs. Crittenden's the nicest way."
Marsh was delighted with this. "There! I hope you're satisfied.
You've been called 'nice.' That ought to please any good
American."
"I wonder, Mr. Welles," Marise said in an ostentatiously casual
tone, "I wonder if Mr. Marsh had been an ancient Greek, and had
stood watching the procession going up the Acropolis hill, bearing
the thank-offerings from field and loom and vineyard, what do you
suppose he would have seen? Dullness and insensitiveness in the
eyes of those Grecian farmer-lads, no doubt, occupied entirely with
keeping the oxen in line; a low vulgar stare of bucolic curiosity
as the country girls, bearing their woven linen, looked up at the
temple. Don't you suppose he would have thought they managed those
things a great deal more artistically in Persia?"
"Well, I don't know much about the ancient Greeks," said Mr.
Welles mildly, "but I guess Vincent would have been about the same
wherever he lived."
"Who is satisfied with the verdict now?" triumphed Marise.
But she noticed that Marsh's attack, although she considered
that she had refuted it rather neatly, had been entirely;
efficacious in destroying the aura of the evening. Of the genuine
warmth of feeling which the flower and the people around it had
roused in her heart, not the faintest trace was left. She had only
a cool interested certainty that her side had a perfectly valid
foundation for arguing purposes. Mr. Marsh had accomplished that,
and more than that, a return from those other centers of feeling to
her preoccupation with his own personality.
He now went on, "But I'm glad to have gone. I saw a great deal
else there than your eccentric plant and the vacancy of mind of
those sons of toil, cursed, soul-destroying toil. For one thing, I
saw a woman of very great beauty. And that is always so much
gained."
"Oh yes," cried Marise, "that's so. I forgot that you could see
that. I've grown so used to the fact that people here don't
understand how splendidly handsome Nelly Powers is. Their taste
doesn't run to the statuesque, you know. They call that grand
silent calm of her, stupidness! Ever since 'Gene brought her here
as a bride, a year after we came to live in Crittenden's, I have
gone out of my way to look at her. You should see her hanging out
the clothes on a windy day. One sculptured massive pose after
another. But even to see her walk across the room and bend that
shining head is thrilling."
"I saw something else, too," went on Marsh, a cool voice
speaking out of the darkness. "I saw that her black, dour husband
is furiously in love with her and furiously jealous of that tall,
ruddy fellow with an expressive face, who stood by the door in
shirt-sleeves and never took his eyes from her."
Marise was silent, startled by this shouting out of something
she had preferred not to formulate.
"Vincent, you see too much," said Mr. Welles resignedly. The
phrase ran from his tongue as though it were a familiar one.
Marise said slowly, "I've sometimes thought that Frank Warner
did go to the Powers' a good deal, but I haven't wanted to think
anything more."
"What possible reason in the world have you for not wanting to?"
asked Marsh with the most authentic accent of vivid and astonished
curiosity.
"What reason . . . ?" she repeated blankly.
He said dispassionately, "I don't like to hear you make
such a flat, conventional, rubber-stamp comment. Why in the world
shouldn't she love a fine, ardent, living man, better than
that knotty, dead branch of a husband? A beautiful woman and a
living, strong, vital man, they belong together. Whom God hath
joined . . . Don't try to tell me that your judgment is maimed by
the Chinese shoes of outworn ideas, such as the binding nature of a
mediaeval ceremony. That doesn't marry anybody, and you know it. If
she's really married to her husband, all right. But if she loves
another man, and knows in her heart that she would live a thousand
times more fully, more deeply with him . . . why, she's not
married to her husband, and nothing can make her. You know
that!"
Marise sprang at the chance to turn his own weapons of mockery
against him. "Upon my word, who's idealizing the Yankee mountaineer
now?" she cried, laughing out as she spoke at the idea of her
literal-minded neighbors dressed up in those trailing rhetorical
robes. "I thought you said they were so dull and insensitive they
could feel nothing but an interest in two-headed calves, and here
they are, characters in an Italian opera. I only wish Nelly Powers
were capable of understanding those grand languages of yours and
then know what she thought of your idea of what's in her mind. And
as for 'Gene's jealousy, I'll swear that it amounts to no more than
a vague dislike for Frank Warner's 'all the time hanging around and
gassin' instead of stickin' to work.' And you forget, in your fine
modern clean-sweep, a few old-fashioned facts like the existence of
three Powers children, dependent on their mother."
"You're just fencing, not really talking," he answered
imperturbably. "You can't pretend to be sincere in trying to pull
that antimacassar home-and-mother stuff on me. Ask Bernard Shaw,
ask Freud, ask Mrs. Gilman, how good it is for children's stronger,
better selves, to live in the enervating, hot-house concentration
on them of an unbalanced, undeveloped woman, who has let everything
else in her personality atrophy except her morbid preoccupation
with her own offspring. That's really the meaning of what's
sentimentally called 'mothering.' Probably it would be the best
thing in the world for the Powers children if their mother ran away
with that fine broth of a lad."
"But Nelly loves her children and they love her!" Marise brought
this out abruptly, impulsively, and felt, as she heard the words,
that they had a flat, naïve sound, out of key with the general
color of this talk, like a C Major chord introduced into Debussy
nuances.
"Not much she doesn't, nor they her. Any honest observer of life
knows that the only sincere relation possible between the young and
the old (after the babies are weaned) is hostility. We hated our
elders, because they got in our way. And they'll hate us as soon as
they get the strength to, because we'll be in their way. And we
will hate them because they will want to push us off the scene.
It's impossible to ignore the gulf. Most human tragedies come from
trying to pretend it's not there."
"Why, Mr. Welles," cried Marise again, "what do you say to such
talk? Don't you find him perfectly preposterous?"
Mr. Welles answered a little absently. "Oh, I'm pretty well used
to him, by now. And all his friends in the city are talking like
that now. It's the fashion. I'm so old that I've seen a good many
fashions in talk come and go. I never could see that people
acted any differently, no matter which way they talk." As he
finished, he drew a long sigh, which had obviously no connection
with what he had been saying. With the sigh, came an emanation from
him of dispirited fatigue. Marise wished she dared draw his hand
upon her arm and ask him to lean on her as they walked.
Nothing more was said for a time. Marise lost herself in the
outdoor wideness of impression that always came to her under a
night sky, where she felt infinity hovering near. She was aware of
nothing but the faint voice of the pines, the distant diminuendo of
the frog's song, the firm elastic quality of the ground under her
feet, so different from the iron rigidity of the winter earth, and
the cool soft pressure of the night-air on her cheeks, when, like
something thrust into her mind from the outside, there rose into
her consciousness, articulate and complete, the reason why she had
shrunk from looking at the photograph of Rocca di Papa. It was
because it was painful to her, intimately painful and humiliating
to remember how she and Neale had felt there, the wild, high things
they had said to each other, that astounding flood of feeling which
had swept them away at the last. What had become of all that? Where
now was that high tide?
Of course she loved Neale, and he loved her; there was nobody
like Neale, yes, all that; but oh! the living flood had been
ebbing, ebbing out of their hearts. They were not alive as
they had been alive when they had clung to each other, there on
that age-old rock, and felt the tide of all the ages lift them
high.
It must have been ebbing for a long time before she realized it
because, hurried, absorbed, surrounded incessantly by small cares
as she was, hustled and jostled in her rôle of mother and
mistress-of-the-house in servantless America, with the primitive
American need to do so much with her own hands, she had not even
had the time to know the stupid, tragic thing that was happening to
her . . . that she was turning into a slow, vegetating plant
instead of a human being. And now she understood the meaning of the
strange dejection she had felt the day when little Mark went off to
school with the others. How curiously jaded and apprehensive she
had felt that morning, and when she had gone downstairs to see the
callers who arrived that day. That was the first time she had
felt that the tide was ebbing.
All this went through her mind with the cruel swiftness of a
sword-flash. And the first reaction to it, involuntary and reflex,
was to crush it instantly down, lest the man walking at her side
should be aware of it. It had come to her with such loud precision
that it seemed it must have been audible.
As she found herself still on the dark country road, cloaked and
protected by the blackness of the starless night, she was struck
with wonder, as though she had never thought of it before, at the
human body, its opaque, inscrutable mystery, the locked, sealed
strong-box of unimaginable secrets which it is. There they were,
the three of them, stepping side by side, brushing each other as
they moved; and as remote from each other as though they were on
different stars. What were the thoughts, powerful, complex, under
perfect control, which were being marshaled in that round, dark
head? She felt a little afraid to think; and turned from the idea
to the other man with relief. She knew (she told herself) as though
she saw inside, the tired, gentle, simple, wistful thoughts that
filled the white head on her other side.
With this, they were again at the house, where the children and
Touclé had preceded them. Paul was laughing and saying,
"Elly's the looniest kid! She's just been saying that Father is
like . . ." Elly, in a panic, sprang up at him, clapping her hand
over his mouth, crying out, "No, Paul, you shan't tell!
Don't!"
The older, stronger child pulled himself away and, holding her
at arm's length, continued, "She said Father was like the end of
her hair that's fastened into her head, and Mother was the end that
flaps in the wind, and Mr. Marsh was like the Eagle Rock brook,
swirly and hurrying the way it is in the spring."
Elly, half crying, came to her mother. "Mother, it's
nasty-horrid in Paul to tell when I didn't want him to."
Marise began taking off the little girl's coat. "It wasn't very
kind in Paul, but there was nothing in those funny little fancies
to hide, dear."
"I didn't care about you and Father!" explained the child. "Only
. . ." She looked at Mr. Marsh from under downbent brows.
"Why, Elly, I am very much complimented, I'm sure," Marsh
hastened to tell her, "to be compared with such a remarkably nice
thing as a brook in spring-time. I didn't suppose any young lady
would ever have such a poetic idea about me."
"Oh . . ." breathed Elly, relieved, "well . . ."
"Do you suppose you little folks can get yourselves to bed
without me?" asked Marise. "If one of you big children will
unbutton Mark in the back, he can manage the rest. I must set a
bread-sponge before I go upstairs."
They clung to her imploringly. "But you'll be upstairs in time
to kiss us good-night in our beds," begged Elly and Mark together.
Paul also visibly hung on his mother's answer.
Marise looked down into their clear eyes and eager faces,
reaching out to her ardently, and she felt her heart melt. What
darlings they were! What inestimable treasures! How sweet to be
loved like that!
She stooped over them and gathered them all into a great armful,
kissing them indiscriminately. "Yes, of course, I will . . . and
give you an extra kiss now!" she cried.
She felt Marsh's eyes on her, sardonically.
She straightened herself, saying with affectionate roughness,
"There, that's enough. Scamper along with you. And don't run around
with bare feet!"
She thought to herself that she supposed this was the sort of
thing Marsh meant when he spoke about hot-house enervating
concentration. She had been more stung by that remark of his than
she had been willing to acknowledge to Marsh or to herself.
But for the moment, any further reflection on it was cut short
by the aspect of Mr. Welles' face. He had sunk into a chair near
the lamp, with an attitude and an expression of such weariness,
that Marise moved quickly to him. "See here, Mr. Welles," she said
impulsively, "you have something on your mind, and I've got the
mother-habit so fastened on me that I can't be discreet and pretend
not to notice it. I want to make you say what the trouble is, and
then flu it right, just as I would for one of mine."
The old man looked up at her gratefully and reaching out one of
his wrinkled hands took hers in it. "It does me good to have you so
nice to me," he said, "but I'm afraid even you can't fix it right.
I've had a rather distressing letter today, and I can't seem to get
it out of my mind."
"Schwatzkummerer can't send the gladioli," conjectured
Marsh.
For the first time since he had entered the house, Marise felt a
passing dislike for him. She had often felt him to be hard and
ruthless, but she had never seen anything cheap in him, before, she
thought.
"What was your letter?" she asked the older man.
"Oh, nothing in the least remarkable, nothing new," he said
heavily. "I've got a cousin whom I haven't seen since she was a
little little girl, though she must be somewhere near my age, now.
She has been a teacher in a school for Negroes, down in Georgia,
for years, most of her life. But I had sort of lost track of her,
till I had to send her some little family trinkets that were left
after my old aunt died. Her letter, that I received today, is in
answer to that. And while she was writing, she gave me her news,
and told me a good deal about conditions down there. Pretty bad, I
should think it, pretty bad."
A little spasm crossed his face. He shook his head, as though to
shake off a clinging filament of importunate thought.
"What's the trouble? Do they need money, the school?" asked
Marise with a vague idea of getting up a contribution.
"No, my cousin didn't say anything about that. It's not so
simple. It's the way the Negroes are treated. No, not lynchings, I
knew about them. But I knew they don't happen every day. What I
hadn't any idea of, till her letter came, was how every day, every
minute of every day, they're subject to indignity that they can't
avoid, how they're made to feel themselves outsiders and unwelcome
in their own country. She says the Southern white people are
willing to give them anything that will make good day-laborers of
them, almost anything in fact except the thing they can't rise
without, ordinary human respect. It made a very painful impression
on my mind, her letter, very. She gave such instances. I haven't
been able to get it out of my mind. For instance, one of the small
things she told me . . . it seems incredible . . . is that Southern
white people won't give the ordinary title of respect of Mr. or
Mrs. or Dr. even to a highly educated Negro. They call them by
their first names, like servants. Think what an hourly pin-prick of
insult that must be. Ever since her letter came, I've been thinking
about it, the things she told me, about what happens when they try
to raise themselves and refine themselves, how they're made to
suffer intimately for trying to be what I thought we all wanted all
Americans to be." He looked at Marise with troubled eyes. "I've
been thinking how it would feel to be a Negro myself. What a
different life would be in front of your little Elly if she had
Negro blood!"
Marise had listened to him in profound silence. Sheer, unmixed
astonishment filled her mind, up to the brim. Of all the totally
unexpected things for Mr. Welles to get wrought up about!
She drew a long breath. How eternally disconcerting human beings
are! There she had been so fatuously sure, out there on the walk
home, that she knew exactly what was in that old white head. And
all the time it had been this. Who could have made the faintest
guess at that? It occurred to her for the first time that possibly
more went on under Mr. Welles' gently fatigued exterior than she
thought.
She found not a word to say, so violent and abrupt was the
transition of subject. It was as though she had been gazing down
through a powerful magnifying glass, trying to untangle with her
eyes a complicated twist of moral fibers, inextricably bound up
with each other, the moral fibers that made up her life . . . and
in the midst of this, someone had roughly shouted in her ear, "Look
up there, at that distant cliff. There's a rock on it, all ready to
fall off!"
She could not be expected all of a sudden, that way, to re-focus
her eyes. And the rock was so far away. And she had such a dim
sense of the people who might be endangered by it. And the
confusion here, under the microscope of her attention, was so vital
and immediate, needing to be understood and straightened before she
could go on with her life.
She looked at the old man in an astonishment which she knew must
seem fairly stupid to him, but she could not bring out anything
else. What was it to her, whether a Negro physician was called Dr.
or "Jo"?
Mr. Welles patted her hand, released it, smiled at her kindly,
and stood up. "I'm pretty tired. I guess we'd better be getting
along home, Vincent and I."
"Well, I should say we would better be getting along home
to bed!" agreed the other man, coming forward and slipping his arm
under the older man's. "I'll tuck you up, my old friend, with a
good hot toddy inside you, and let you sleep off this outrageously
crazy daylight nightmare you've cooked up for yourself. And don't
wake up with the fate of the Japanese factory-hand sitting on your
chest, or you'll get hard to live with."
Mr. Welles answered this with literal good faith. "Oh, the
Japanese factory-hands, they're not on the conscience of
Americans."
"But, when I see an aged and harmless inhabitant of Ashley,
Vermont, stretching his poor old protesting conscience till it
cracks, to make it reach clear down to the Georgia Negroes, how do
I know where he's going to stop?"
The old man turned to their hostess. "Well, good-night, Mrs.
Crittenden. I enjoyed seeing that wonderful flower very much. I
wonder if I could grow one like it? It would be something to look
forward to, to have the flower open in your own house."
To Marise he looked so sweet and good, and like a tired old
child, that she longed to kiss him good-night, as she had her own.
But even as she felt the impulse, she had again a startled sense of
how much more goes on under the human surface than ever appears.
Evidently Mr. Welles, too, was a locked and sealed strong-box of
secrets.
In the doorway Marsh stopped abruptly and said, looking at the
dense, lustreless black silk wrap about Marise's head and
shoulders, "What's that thing? I meant to ask you when you put it
on."
She felt as she often did when he spoke to her, as startled as
though he had touched her. What an extraordinarily living presence
he was, so that a word from him was almost like an actual personal
contact. But she took care not to show this. She looked down
casually at the soft, opaque folds of her wrap. "Oh, this is a
thousand years old. It dates from the Bayonne days. It's Basque.
It's their variation, I imagine, on the Spanish mantilla. They
never wear hats, the Basque women. The little girls, when they have
made their first communion, wear a scarf of light net, or open
transparent lace. And when they marry they wear this. It's made of
a special sort of silk, woven just for this purpose. As far away as
you can see a woman in the Basque country, if she wears this, you
know she's married."
"Oh, you do, do you?" said Marsh, going out after his
companion.
They were very far from the Negroes in Georgia.